Broker Comparison Checklist: 15 Factors to Evaluate

Comprehensive checklist for comparing brokers. Learn the 15 most important factors to evaluate before choosing your trading broker.

Financial Technology

When comparing brokers for LATAM trading, check these 7 factors in order: (1) regulation status, (2) spread/commission costs on your pairs, (3) local payment method support, (4) minimum deposit, (5) platform quality, (6) withdrawal speed, (7) customer support in Spanish. This checklist helps you make an informed choice.

When comparing brokers for LATAM trading, check these 7 factors in order: (1) regulation status, (2) spread/commission costs on your pairs, (3) local payment method support, (4) minimum deposit, (5) platform quality, (6) withdrawal speed, (7) customer support in Spanish. This checklist helps you make an informed choice.

Last updated: January 27, 2026

Broker Comparison Checklist: 15 Factors to Evaluate

Don't choose a broker based on ads or bonuses. Use this systematic checklist to evaluate every option.

✅ Factor #1: Regulation & Safety

What to check:

  • Regulated by FCA, CySEC, or ASIC? ✅
  • License number visible and verifiable? ✅
  • Segregated client funds? ✅
  • Negative balance protection? ✅
  • Years in operation? (5+ years preferred)

Red flags: No regulation, can't verify license, promises seem too good

Weight: 🔴 CRITICAL - Skip broker if fails

Learn more: Regulation Guide


💰 Factor #2: Spreads & Commissions

What to compare:

Pair Libertex eToro XTB IC Markets
EUR/USD 0.8 pips 1.0 pips 0.9 pips 0.6 pips
GBP/USD 1.2 pips 1.5 pips 1.1 pips 0.9 pips
USD/JPY 1.0 pips 1.2 pips 1.0 pips 0.7 pips

Commission models:

  • Zero-commission: Earn via spread (Libertex, eToro)
  • Commission-based: Tight spreads + small commission (IC Markets)

Calculate: Your trading frequency × cost per trade

Full fee comparison →


📱 Factor #3: Platform Quality

Rate each platform 1-5:

Ease of use: Can you navigate without confusion?
Mobile app: Is mobile version good?
Charting tools: Enough indicators and drawing tools?
Order types: Limit, stop, trailing stop available?
Speed: Orders execute quickly without slippage?
Reliability: Platform crashes/bugs?

Test: Use demo account for 1 week minimum


💵 Factor #4: Minimum Deposit

Broker Minimum
XTB $0
Interactive Brokers $0
eToro $50-100
Exness $1
Libertex $100-200
Pepperstone $200
Saxo Bank $10,000

Consider: What you can afford to lose, not just minimum


🌍 Factor #5: LATAM Payment Methods

Check for your country:

Mexico: SPEI, OXXO?
Colombia: PSE?
Argentina: Crypto/USDT?
General: Cards, e-wallets?

Also check:

  • Deposit fees
  • Withdrawal fees
  • Processing times
  • Currency conversion rates

Payment methods guide →


📚 Factor #6: Educational Resources

Evaluate:

  • Video courses available?
  • Webinars in Spanish/Portuguese?
  • Trading guides and articles?
  • Demo account quality?
  • Economic calendar provided?
  • Daily market analysis?

Best for education:

  • XTB: Extensive academy
  • eToro: Social learning
  • Libertex: Basic but clear guides

Weight: High for beginners, low for experienced


🎓 Factor #7: Account Types

Check options:

Demo account: Free? Unlimited time?
Standard account: Most common
Islamic account: Swap-free for Muslim traders
ECN/Raw spreads: Lower spreads, small commission
Cent account: Practice with tiny amounts

Your needs: Beginners usually want standard + demo


🛠️ Factor #8: Trading Tools

Essential features:

✅ Economic calendar
✅ Market news feed
✅ Price alerts
✅ Technical indicators
✅ Multiple timeframes
✅ Chart drawing tools

Advanced features:

  • Backtesting
  • Copy trading
  • Algorithmic trading
  • API access
  • Multi-chart layouts

Evaluate: Match tools to your trading style


📞 Factor #9: Customer Support

Test before depositing:

Questions to ask:

  1. "What are your withdrawal times?"
  2. "Do you support [your country]?"
  3. "What's the spread on EUR/USD?"
  4. "Can I use [your payment method]?"

Evaluate:

  • Response speed (under 2 minutes for chat?)
  • Answer quality (detailed or vague?)
  • Language support (Spanish/Portuguese available?)
  • Availability (24/5 or business hours only?)
  • Multiple channels (chat, email, phone?)

Red flags:

  • Pushy sales tactics
  • Avoiding direct questions
  • No live chat
  • Only email support

💻 Factor #10: MetaTrader 4/5 Support

Why it matters: Industry-standard platforms

Brokers offering MT4/MT5: ✅ Libertex, XTB, Pepperstone, IC Markets, Exness, FXCM

❌ eToro, Interactive Brokers (proprietary only)

Consider: If you want to use Expert Advisors (automated trading), MT4/5 essential

Otherwise: Proprietary platforms often better for beginners (eToro)


🌐 Factor #11: Available Markets

What can you trade?

Broker Forex Pairs Stocks Indices Commodities Crypto
Interactive Brokers 100+ 30,000+ 50+ 30+ Limited
Libertex 50+ 700+ 20+ 15+ 20+
eToro 50+ 3,000+ 15+ 10+ 70+
XTB 50+ 2,000+ 30+ 20+ Limited
Pepperstone 60+ CFDs 15+ 10+ 20+

Your needs: Beginners usually fine with 20-30 forex pairs + major stocks


💼 Factor #12: Copy Trading / Social Features

eToro: Industry leader

  • Copy successful traders automatically
  • See what others trade
  • Social feed discussions

Other brokers:

  • Most don't have social features
  • Some offer signal services
  • Usually rely on your own analysis

Good for: Beginners wanting to learn, or passive investors

eToro Copy Trading Review →


📊 Factor #13: Withdrawal Speed & Reliability

Test: Check reviews specifically about withdrawals

Acceptable:

  • E-wallets: 1-2 days
  • Cards: 3-7 days
  • Bank transfer: 3-5 days

Warning signs:

  • "Pending" for weeks
  • Requires re-verification repeatedly
  • Excuses and delays
  • Impossible terms to withdraw bonuses

This is WHERE scam brokers reveal themselves.


🎁 Factor #14: Bonuses & Promotions

Our take: Nice-to-have, NOT a deciding factor

Why be careful:

  • Bonuses have strict terms (30-40x volume requirements)
  • Can lock your funds
  • Not worth choosing worse broker for bonus

Better: Choose based on spreads, regulation, platform—ignore bonuses

Exception: Cashback programs (no strings attached)


🌟 Factor #15: Reputation & Reviews

Where to check:

  • Trustpilot reviews
  • Forex Peace Army
  • Our detailed reviews
  • Reddit r/Forex discussions

Look for:

  • Overall rating (4.0+ out of 5)
  • Withdrawal complaints (most important!)
  • Platform stability
  • Customer service feedback
  • Recent reviews (not just old ones)

Warning: Ignore obviously fake positive reviews

See our verified reviews →


📋 Your Broker Evaluation Scorecard

Rate each broker 1-5 on these factors:

Factor Weight Broker A Broker B Broker C
Regulation 10x __/5 __/5 __/5
Spreads/Fees 8x __/5 __/5 __/5
Platform 7x __/5 __/5 __/5
Payment Methods 6x __/5 __/5 __/5
Customer Support 5x __/5 __/5 __/5
Education 4x __/5 __/5 __/5
Withdrawal Speed 8x __/5 __/5 __/5

Calculate: Multiply score by weight, sum total

Highest score = best broker for YOUR needs


🎯 Quick Recommendation by Profile

Complete Beginner:

eToro (easiest, social learning)

Cost-Conscious:

Libertex (zero commissions)

Advanced Trader:

Interactive Brokers (pro tools)

Active Day Trader:

Pepperstone or IC Markets (tightest spreads)

Mexico-Based:

XTB or Libertex (SPEI support)

Argentina-Based:

Libertex or Exness (crypto-friendly)

Compare all brokers →


❓ FAQ

Q: How many brokers should I compare?
A: 3-5 brokers thoroughly is better than 20 superficially.

Q: Should I open accounts with multiple brokers?
A: Not as beginner. Master one first. Later, having 2 brokers makes sense (backup, different strengths).

Q: What if "best" broker isn't available in my country?
A: Focus on available options. Every LATAM country has at least 3-5 solid choices.

Q: Do broker comparisons change frequently?
A: Yes. Re-evaluate yearly. Brokers improve/decline, regulations change, new options emerge.


Last updated: January 2026

Related: Full Broker Comparison Tool | Best Regulated Brokers

Bottom Line

Use this checklist every time you evaluate a new broker. Don't skip regulation verification — it's the single most important factor. After safety, focus on costs (spreads and commissions), then platform quality. Everything else is secondary.

Key Takeaways

Remember these important points:

  • 1 Risk management is the most important skill in trading
  • 2 Never risk more than 1-2% per trade
  • 3 Always use stop losses - no exceptions

Related Articles

🛡️

Risk Management

Learn to protect your capital

Learn to read charts

Create your strategy

Ready to get started? Find My Broker
🎯 Ready to Find Your Perfect Broker?
Answer 4 quick questions and get personalized recommendations in 60 seconds
Get Started →